The man most responsible for the rocket that took Apollo 11 to the Moon had spent the Second World War building the V-2 for Nazi Germany, with a factory staffed by concentration camp prisoners. That uncomfortable fact sits at the centre of Operation Paperclip, the US programme that brought German scientists and engineers to America after 1945. It is often summed up as a secret deal to forgive the war crimes of 1,600 Nazi scientists. The truth is less tidy.
Quick Facts
- Programme: Operation Paperclip, run by the Joint Intelligence Objectives Agency
- Numbers: 765 scientists, engineers and technicians brought to the US 1945–1955 (US National Archives); case files on more than 1,500
- Nazi Party members: Up to 80 percent, according to historian Clarence Lasby
- Von Braun: Nazi Party from 1937, SS from 1940, rank of Sturmbannführer (major)
- Mittelbau-Dora: About 60,000 prisoners sent; 20,000 or more died
- Later career: Director of NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center, 1960–1970; chief architect of the Saturn V
How Many, and Who
The figure of 1,600 comes from journalist Annie Jacobsen’s 2014 book Operation Paperclip. The US National Archives’ Interagency Working Group put the number brought to the United States between 1945 and 1955 at 765 scientists, engineers and technicians, while its case files cover more than 1,500 German and other foreign specialists. Not all were Nazis, but many were: historian Clarence Lasby, cited by the National Archives, estimated that up to 80 percent had been Nazi Party members.

No Amnesty, but Cleaned-Up Files
There was no formal pardon. President Truman ordered that only nominal party members, not active supporters of Nazism, be admitted. What happened in practice, the National Archives report says, is that the Joint Intelligence Objectives Agency asked Army counter-intelligence to revise some security reports so that certain scientists could take part. The scientists’ value against the Soviet Union outweighed their pasts.
Von Braun and Buchenwald
Wernher von Braun joined the Nazi Party in 1937 and the SS in 1940, rising to the rank of Sturmbannführer. His V-2 was built at the Mittelwerk, an underground factory worked by prisoners of the Mittelbau-Dora camp. According to Michael Neufeld, his biographer and a curator at the Smithsonian’s National Air and Space Museum, between 20,000 and 25,000 of about 60,000 prisoners sent to the Mittelbau camp system died; at least twice as many people died producing the V-2 as were killed by it.
The claim that von Braun personally picked prisoners at Buchenwald rests on his own letter of 15 August 1944, in which he wrote that he had gone to Buchenwald to find suitable prisoners. Neufeld concluded that von Braun probably arranged a transfer of skilled prisoners for a laboratory project, which in theory implicates him in crimes against humanity. The scale and the place matter: those prisoners were a handful of specialists, and the mass deaths happened at the Mittelwerk factory and the Dora camp, run by the SS and the factory managers, not in “his lab”.
Historian Michael Neufeld on von Braun and the V-2. Video: The National WWII Museum.
From the V-2 to Apollo
In America, von Braun’s team built missiles for the US Army before moving to NASA in 1960, when he became the first director of the Marshall Space Flight Center in Huntsville. NASA calls him the chief architect of the Saturn V, the rocket that launched Apollo 11 in July 1969; it was designed by a large team of NASA and industry engineers under his leadership. Another Paperclip engineer, Arthur Rudolph, who had run operations at the Mittelwerk and later managed the Saturn V programme, gave up his US citizenship in 1984 under an agreement with the Justice Department’s Office of Special Investigations.

Documentary on von Braun and the Saturn V. Video: Spark.
A Deal With the Past
The United States did bring German scientists, many of them former Nazis, to America to work on weapons for the Cold War, and records were softened to let them in. Von Braun was an SS officer, went to Buchenwald to select prisoners, and later led the development of the Saturn V. But 1,600 is one author’s count, not an official figure; there was no formal amnesty for war crimes; and the prisoners who worked and died for the V-2 did so in the tunnels of the Mittelwerk and the Dora camp.
The rocket that carried Apollo 11 to the Moon was built by men whose past America chose not to look at too closely.
Sources: US National Archives, Nazi War Crimes and Japanese Imperial Government Records Interagency Working Group, Final Report (2007), and RG 330 foreign scientist case files; Michael J. Neufeld, “Wonder Weapons and Slave Labor”, Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum (2020), and exchange with Ernst Stuhlinger in German Studies Review 26:1 (2003); NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, Wernher von Braun biography; US Holocaust Memorial Museum, Dora-Mittelbau; Mittelbau-Dora Memorial; PBS American Experience; Christian Science Monitor (5 September 1985); Annie Jacobsen, Operation Paperclip (2014).




0 Comments