On 13 December 2008, Steven Rothstein walked up to the American Airlines counter at Chicago O’Hare to check in for a transatlantic flight, as he had done thousands of times before. Instead of a boarding pass he was handed a letter. His AAirpass, the ticket that had let him fly first class anywhere on American, as often as he liked, for the rest of his life, was cancelled with immediate effect for “fraudulent behavior”.
Rothstein had bought it 21 years earlier. By then he had collected more than 30 million miles.
Quick Facts
- Launched: 1981, to raise cash for expansion during record-high interest rates
- What it gave: Unlimited first-class travel for life, miles on every trip, lifetime Admirals Club membership
- Companion option: An add-on costing 60% of the pass itself
- Price rises: By 1993 the pass with companion cost about four times the original 1981 price
- Withdrawn: 1994; a final 2004 catalogue offer found no buyers
- Unlimited holders: 66, according to the Los Angeles Times
- Revoked: Steven Rothstein (December 2008) and Jacques Vroom (July 2008), among others
A Bond Paid in Air Travel
The idea was born in 1981. American Airlines had lost money the year before, interest rates were at record highs, and its new president, Robert Crandall, needed cash to expand. The AAirpass raised it upfront: a single payment bought unlimited first-class travel for life, with frequent-flyer miles on every flight and membership of the Admirals Club lounges. For a further 60 percent of the price, a buyer could add a companion pass and bring anyone along. Older buyers got a discount based on their age.
American imagined companies buying passes for their top executives. Instead, private individuals worked out what the airline had not: a heavy traveller would get his money back within a few years, and everything after that was free.

The Man Who Flew Every Other Day
Steven Rothstein, a Chicago stockbroker, bought his pass in 1987, aged 37, and added the companion option about two years later. He was, according to the Los Angeles Times, airborne almost every other day. He flew to San Francisco to pick up a friend and carried on to Paris for an exhibition at the Louvre. In July 2004 alone he took 18 flights. He gave first-class seats to strangers, and once flew a woman he had just met from New Delhi to Chicago.
He saw it as an investment that paid out in travel instead of interest. “They needed cash, and they could pay me in miles,” he told The Hustle in 2018. In 1998 Crandall himself wrote to him, promising that American would “honor the deal, far into the future.”

The story of the AAirpass. Video: Half as Interesting.
The Airline Starts Counting
Other holders flew just as hard. Jacques Vroom, a Dallas marketing consultant, piled up almost 38 million miles; a flight attendant named Pierre would bring him three salmon appetizers and a glass of champagne without being asked. Baseball legend Willie Mays and the America’s Cup skipper Dennis Conner also held passes. American raised the price repeatedly through the 1990s and stopped selling unlimited passes altogether in 1994.
In 2007, with the airline under pressure, a pricing analyst flagged how much the pass holders were costing. American’s revenue integrity unit calculated that Rothstein and Vroom were each costing the airline more than a million dollars a year in lost seats, taxes and miles, about four times what Rothstein had originally paid for his pass, every year. Investigators found Rothstein had made 3,009 reservations in under four years and cancelled 2,523 of them. He had also booked his companion seat under names such as “Steven Rothstein Jr.” to keep the seat beside him empty, something American had told him to stop in 2004.
Vroom’s pass was revoked first, in July 2008, in the American lounge at Heathrow, after the airline accused him of selling his companion seats. He said the money he received was for business advice and that the contract never banned selling seats. Rothstein’s followed in December.
In Court
Rothstein sued in March 2009. American countersued for fraud. In June 2011 a federal judge in Chicago ruled for the airline on Rothstein’s contract claim, pointing to the pass’s fraud clause: if American determined a pass had been used fraudulently, it could revoke it without refund. The airline’s own counterclaims were frozen when its parent company filed for bankruptcy in November 2011 and were later dropped. Vroom’s case in Texas was frozen by the same bankruptcy. Neither man got his pass back, and neither was ever charged with a crime.
Rothstein, looking back, was blunt. “I wish I’d never bought the thing,” he told The Hustle. Crandall was just as blunt about the holders who lost their passes: “I assume they were cheaters. If they were cheaters, they deserved it.”
How the AAirpass worked and why it failed. Video: Simple Flying.
The Last Golden Ticket
American tried once more in 2004, offering a lifetime unlimited pass in the Neiman Marcus Christmas catalogue at twelve times the 1981 price, plus a companion pass. Nobody bought it. Some AAirpasses still exist, but the unlimited lifetime first-class ticket is gone for good, remembered as the airline deal that was, for a lucky few, exactly as good as it sounded.
Sources: Ken Bensinger, “The frequent fliers who flew too much”, Los Angeles Times (5 May 2012); Rothstein v. American Airlines, US District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, case 1:09-cv-02770, opinions of 30 June 2011 and 10 February 2012; Zachary Crockett, The Hustle (7 April 2018); New York Post, via Fox News (13 May 2012); Caroline Rothstein, Narratively (22 July 2019); Texas Monthly (21 January 2013); CBS Texas (8 May 2012); NPR, All Things Considered (8 May 2012).




0 Comments