Pilot Incapacitation: What the Other Pilot Does, and Why There Are Two

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Monde de l'aviation | 0 comments

Somewhere over the North Atlantic on 28 January 2008, the captain of an Air Canada Boeing 767 bound from Toronto to London Heathrow made a decision no checklist covers. His first officer, who had arrived late and “harried”, had become rambling, then belligerent and uncooperative. The captain called the lead flight attendant and had his colleague removed from the flight deck.

With 146 passengers behind him and a possible low-visibility autoland at Heathrow ahead, he diverted to Shannon. A flight attendant who held a commercial pilot’s licence took the right-hand seat. Ireland’s Air Accident Investigation Unit later reported that the descent, approach and landing were uneventful.

That is pilot incapacitation, and it is the clearest answer to a question passengers often ask: why does an airliner need two pilots at all? Here is what the second pilot actually does when the first one stops being a pilot.

Informations clés

  • Qu'est-ce que c'est : A pilot becoming physically or mentally unable to perform flight duties
  • Two types: Obvious (sudden collapse, illness) and subtle (hypoxia, low blood sugar, fatigue, stroke)
  • Déclenchement: No normal response to two consecutive challenges, or to one significant warning (Transport Canada TP 11629; IFALPA Two Communication Rule)
  • First action: Fly the aircraft: keep control, climb to a safe altitude, use the autopilot
  • How often: About 1 in every 34,000 high-capacity flights in Australia, 2010-2014 (ATSB)
  • Main cause: Gastrointestinal illness, about half of airline cases (ATSB)
  • Defence: Two pilots, different meals, incapacitation training
  • Radio call: MAYDAY for distress, PAN-PAN for urgency, depending on the situation

Obvious, and the kind that hides

Training material divides incapacitation into the dramatic and the quiet. Transport Canada’s guidance on the subject, publication TP 11629, as summarised by Flight Safety Foundation, names gastrointestinal problems such as cramps, nausea and diarrhoea as the leading causes of sudden incapacitation, and heart problems and fainting as the main causes of serious incapacitation.

The dangerous kind is subtle. Hypoxia, low blood sugar, extreme fatigue, alcohol, drugs, toxic substances and strokes can leave a pilot sitting upright, eyes open, apparently working, while no longer making sense. It tends to show up when workload is high, which is exactly when the other pilot is busiest.

“The victim may not respond to stimulus, may make illogical decisions or may appear to be manipulating controls in an ineffective or hazardous manner”
Transport Canada TP 11629 — Guidance on pilot incapacitation, as quoted by Flight Safety Foundation, 2009

The Air Canada case shows how gradual it can be. According to the Irish report, the warning signs mounted for hours, from the late arrival and the trips out of the flight deck to disjointed conversation, before the captain concluded he was dealing with a crew member who was effectively incapacitated.

Air Canada Boeing 767-300ER C-FTCA on final approach with landing gear down against a blue sky
An Air Canada Boeing 767-300ER on approach to Montreal in February 2009. It was a 767-300 of the same airline whose first officer had to be removed from the flight deck on the way from Toronto to Heathrow in January 2008; this is not that aircraft. Photo: Jean-Philippe Boulet / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

The two-communication rule

Because subtle incapacitation is so hard to spot, airlines use a trigger rather than a hunch. The Transport Canada guidance says that if a pilot does not respond normally to two consecutive challenges, or to one significant warning such as descending below decision height without the required visual references, the other pilot should act. The International Federation of Air Line Pilots’ Associations formalised the same idea as the “Two Communication Rule” in its 2025 position paper on incapacitation training.

What happens next is drilled. The first priority is to fly the aircraft: do whatever is necessary to keep control, and restrain the incapacitated pilot only as much as needed to protect the controls. Then climb to and hold a safe altitude, go around if an approach has become unstable, and engage the autopilot at a safe height to cut the workload. The guidance suggests saying actions out loud to stay organised.

BAA Training’s demonstration of how cabin crew and the remaining pilot handle an in-flight pilot incapacitation.

Cabin crew are part of the drill. They are trained to secure the incapacitated pilot by moving the seat fully aft and tightening the shoulder harness, or to remove the pilot from the seat altogether. Afterburner’s piece on why flight attendants sit on their hands explains how much of that crew role is rehearsed in advance. The remaining pilot then lands at the nearest suitable airport, ideally with help: in the Air Canada case, the captain asked the cabin crew to check the passenger list for any company pilots on board.

Mayday or Pan-Pan?

Pilots and passengers alike ask which call to make. The FAA’s Pilot/Controller Glossary defines distress, signalled by MAYDAY, as being threatened by serious or imminent danger and requiring immediate assistance. Urgency, signalled by PAN-PAN, is a condition of concern about safety requiring timely but not immediate assistance. The choice depends on the situation, not on the word “incapacitation”.

A pilot alone at the controls on short final with a collapsed colleague is in a very different position from one in stable cruise with a sick colleague strapped in the back. In the Air Canada diversion, AvWeb’s summary of the investigation says the captain made a PAN call. Either way, the call buys priority, and controllers will clear the way for the nearest suitable runway.

Captain’s hand on the thrust levers of an Airbus A320 family aircraft during a visual approach to Nice, with the first officer’s arm visible on the right
Two pilots sharing the work on an Airbus A320 family approach into Nice: the captain, flying, adjusts the thrust levers while the first officer monitors. If one stops responding, the other takes over all of it. Photo: Olivier Cleynen / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

How often it happens, and why the meals differ

Pilot incapacitation is rare. The Australian Transport Safety Bureau counted 113 flight crew incapacitation occurrences reported between 2010 and 2014, 86 of them in high-capacity air transport. That works out at about 29 per million departures, or one every 34,000 flights. Half were gastrointestinal illness such as food poisoning or gastroenteritis; laser strikes came next. With two pilots aboard, the ATSB found, these events usually had minimal effect on the flight.

“In high capacity air transport operations, the practice of ensuring all pilots on the same flight eat different meals prior to and during the flight has been an effective defence preventing all pilots on the same flight becoming incapacitated at the same time.”
Bureau australien de la sécurité des transports — Pilot incapacitation occurrences 2010–2014, report AR-2015-096, 2016

That is the logic behind the old rule that captain and first officer eat different meals. One bad chicken dish can take out one pilot. It should not take out both. An earlier ATSB study, of 98 incapacitation events from 1975 to 2006, found that all ten fatal accidents among them involved single-pilot operations, according to Flight Safety Foundation’s summary.

What if both pilots go down?

It is the question every passenger eventually asks, and the honest answer is that the system is built to stop it happening rather than to cope afterwards. Different meals, medical certification, and the two-communication rule all aim to make sure one pilot is always functioning. In smaller aircraft, technology now offers a last resort: emergency autoland systems such as Garmin’s, now certified on types including the Pilatus PC-12 PRO, can land the aircraft at the press of a button.

Fly with Magnar on EASA’s look at single-pilot operations, and the problems the second pilot solves.

The two-pilot model is under pressure from another direction. Europe’s regulator has studied extended minimum crew operations, or eMCO, in which a single pilot would fly the cruise while the other rests. EASA’s research project lists pilot incapacitation among the specific issues it examined, and in January 2025 EASA pushed its expected decision on reduced-crew operations from 2027 to 2030, according to Aviacionline. In the US, the FAA moved the other way on older business jets, ending single-pilot exemptions for older Cessna Citations.

For now, the reason for the second seat is the one the Air Canada captain discovered over the Atlantic. Engines and computers have backups. So does the pilot.

Sources: Australian Transport Safety Bureau (AR-2015-096), Flight Safety Foundation AeroSafety World (January 2009, citing Transport Canada TP 11629 and the Irish AAIU), The Irish Times, AvWeb, African Pilot (IFALPA 25POS14), FAA Pilot/Controller Glossary and AIM 6-3-1, EASA (eMCO-SiPO research project), Aviacionline

Header photo: Jetstar Airways / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Foire aux questions

What happens if a pilot becomes incapacitated in flight?
The other pilot takes control and flies the aircraft first, restraining the incapacitated pilot only as needed to protect the controls. Cabin crew secure the pilot, with the seat moved fully aft and the harness tightened, or help remove them from the seat. The flight then normally diverts to the nearest suitable airport.
What is the two-communication rule for pilots?
The two-communication rule says that if a pilot does not respond normally to two consecutive verbal challenges, or to one significant warning such as going below decision height without visual references, the other pilot should suspect incapacitation and take over. IFALPA formalised it in its 2025 guidance on incapacitation training.
What is subtle pilot incapacitation?
Subtle incapacitation is a partial loss of function where the pilot may seem normal but stops responding properly, makes illogical decisions or handles the controls ineffectively. Common causes include hypoxia, low blood sugar, extreme fatigue, alcohol, drugs and strokes. It is considered more dangerous than sudden collapse because it is harder to spot.
Should a pilot declare Mayday or Pan-Pan for an incapacitated pilot?
It depends on the situation. MAYDAY signals distress, meaning serious or imminent danger requiring immediate assistance; PAN-PAN signals urgency, a safety concern needing timely but not immediate help. In the 2008 Air Canada diversion to Shannon, the captain made a PAN call, according to AvWeb’s summary of the investigation.
Why do pilots eat different meals?
Pilots on the same flight eat different meals so that food poisoning cannot incapacitate both at once. The Australian Transport Safety Bureau found about half of airline pilot incapacitations in 2010 to 2014 were gastrointestinal illness, and called the different-meals practice an effective defence against all pilots becoming incapacitated together.
How common is pilot incapacitation?
Pilot incapacitation is rare. The Australian Transport Safety Bureau recorded 86 incapacitation occurrences in high-capacity air transport from 2010 to 2014, about 29 per million departures or one every 34,000 flights. With two pilots on board, these events usually had minimal effect on the flight.
Why do airliners have two pilots?
Two pilots provide redundancy for the one system that cannot be duplicated in hardware: the human at the controls. If one pilot falls ill or becomes impaired, the other can fly and land the aircraft. EASA has studied single-pilot cruise operations, but treats pilot incapacitation as one of the key safety issues to resolve.

Articles similaires

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *