The engines are pulling at full power, the cargo floor is loaded far beyond anything the designers intended, and ahead lies a wall of rock and ice that reaches above 20,000 feet. Somewhere on the far side is China. For the crews of Air Transport Command in 1944, this was an ordinary working day in a Curtiss C-46 Commando.
The C-46 was never meant to be a warplane. It was born as a sleek, pressurised airliner, and it went on to haul fuel, ammunition, livestock and men across the most dangerous air route of the Second World War. Its crews called it the Whale, the Curtiss Calamity and, with grim humour, the flying coffin. They also kept China in the war with it.
Kurzinfo
- Typ: Twin-engined military transport, developed from the Curtiss-Wright CW-20 airliner
- Erster Flug: CW-20 prototype, 26 March 1940
- Into service: USAAF deliveries from July 1942
- Motoren: 2 × Pratt & Whitney R-2800 Double Wasp radials, 2,000 hp each
- Accepted by the AAF: 3,144 in the Second World War; US Marine Corps version: R5C
- Best known for: The Hump airlift from India to China, from 1943
- Spitznamen: The Whale, Curtiss Calamity, plumber’s nightmare, flying coffin
- USAF retirement: 1968; civil freighters flew on into the 21st century
An airliner with a figure-eight body
The story starts in 1937, when Curtiss-Wright chief designer George A. Page Jr. began work on the CW-20, a private-venture airliner meant to beat the four-engined Douglas DC-4 and Boeing 307 Stratoliner with just two engines. Its most distinctive feature was the fuselage: two overlapping circular sections that met at the cabin floor, giving it a “figure-eight” or double-bubble cross-section that was strong enough to be pressurised.
The CW-20 prototype first flew on 26 March 1940 with twin tail fins, which were soon replaced by a large single fin for better low-speed stability. Airlines were curious, but the US Army Air Corps was more than curious. It ordered a militarised version in 1940 as the C-46 Commando, and deliveries to the Army Air Forces began in July 1942.
The prototype itself had an odd career. The Army bought it for evaluation as the C-55, then returned it to Curtiss-Wright, and it ended up flying for the British Overseas Airways Corporation. The airliner the CW-20 was designed to be never went into production; the war turned it into a freighter instead.
The military version dropped the pressurisation, gained a strengthened floor and big cargo doors, and switched to two 2,000 hp Pratt & Whitney R-2800 Double Wasp radials. The C-46A could carry 15,000 lb of cargo or 40 troops on folding seats. The Army Air Forces accepted 3,144 C-46s, while the US Marine Corps flew its own as the R5C.
Over the Hump
When the Japanese cut the Burma Road in 1942, the only way to supply Chiang Kai-shek’s armies and the American air units in China was by air, from bases in north-east India over the eastern Himalayas. Pilots called that route the Hump. Afterburner has told the full story of the airlift; the C-46 was the aircraft that carried much of it.
C-46 flights over the Hump began in 1943. The Commando could lift more than the C-47 Skytrain, climb better with a heavy load and fly higher, which mattered over mountains that left little room for error. It carried fuel drums, ammunition, artillery, aircraft parts and, on occasion, livestock.
That performance came at a price. The C-46 had been rushed into production, and by November 1943 Curtiss-Wright had recorded 721 required changes to production aircraft. Ground crews in India, working in heat, monsoon rain and mud with too few trained hands, came to call it the “plumber’s nightmare”.
Military Aviation History’s look at the C-46 Commando and its reputation as a deathtrap.
Why crews called it a flying coffin
The worst problem was fire. Between May 1943 and March 1945, Air Transport Command received reports of 31 C-46s that caught fire or exploded in the air, and others simply vanished. The cause was eventually traced to the fuel system: small leaks in the unvented wings let petrol pool at the wing root, where a single spark from an open-contact electrical switch could set it off.
The official history of the Army Air Forces did not soften its verdict. It praised the aircraft’s usefulness but described an aeroplane that devoured maintenance hours and, in its own blunt words, “was a killer”.
After the war, every C-46 received wing vents to drain pooled fuel, an explosion-proof booster pump and shielded electrical switches. The fix worked. But for the Hump crews it came too late, and the nickname stuck.
The Rhine, Korea and beyond
The Commando reached Europe only in March 1945, just in time for Operation Varsity, the airborne crossing of the Rhine near Wesel. Seventy-two C-46s carried paratroopers of the US 17th Airborne Division, and roughly 20 were shot down. Unlike most of the C-47s on the operation, they had no self-sealing fuel tanks, and they flew low and slow in daylight over heavy German flak.
It went on serving. USAF C-46s flew supply, paratroop and covert missions in Korea, and the type saw early Vietnam War service with the 1st Air Commando Group before the US Air Force finally retired it in 1968. Surplus C-46s also flew for Israel in 1948 and for the CIA’s airline Civil Air Transport, whose pilots Afterburner followed at Dien Bien Phu.

A second life at the end of the road
Civilian life did not start smoothly. In the United States the C-46 initially could not be certified for scheduled passenger service, so it went to freight carriers and to the so-called irregular airlines, which flew under separate rules. A string of accidents in the early 1950s led regulators to cut its permitted weights and push operators into modification programmes such as the Super 46 and Riddle’s C-46R.
Where it really found a home was at the edges of the map. Its climb rate and ceiling made it a favourite over the mountains and jungles of South America, from Bolivia and Peru to Brazil. In Canada and Alaska, it became a rugged bush freighter that could take a heavy load into a short gravel strip in the cold.

Buffalo Airways in Canada’s Northwest Territories kept C-46s working into the 21st century, hauling freight to communities beyond the road network. More than eight decades after the first CW-20 flew, a design conceived as a luxury airliner is still remembered as one of the toughest freighters ever built.
The C-46 Commando “Tinker Belle” arrives at her new home at the Military Aviation Museum in Virginia Beach.
The C-46 was never as loved as the C-47. It was bigger, thirstier, harder to maintain and, in its early years, far less forgiving. But when the Allies needed to move more cargo higher over the worst terrain on earth, they reached for the Commando. It was a flawed aeroplane that did an impossible job.
Sources: The Army Air Forces in World War II, Vol. 7 (official history), Museum of Aviation (Robins AFB), National Museum of the US Air Force, Pima Air & Space Museum, HistoryOfWar.org, Wikipedia (Curtiss C-46 Commando; Operation Varsity)
Header photo: US Army Air Forces photo / Wikimedia Commons, public domain




0 Comments