Justin Bronk: Drones Won’t Win Wars, and Switzerland Could Fly Gripens

by | Nov 18, 2026 | Militärische Luftfahrt, Nachricht | 0 comments

Every time Switzerland argues about its F-35 purchase, someone says manned fighters are a thing of the past in a world of drones and missiles. Justin Bronk disagrees. The Senior Research Fellow for Airpower and Technology at the Royal United Services Institute in London, one of the best-known air power analysts in Europe, told the Zurich daily Tages-Anzeiger on 12 November 2026 that the drone revolution is real on the ground but not in the air. He also said Switzerland could do the job with a simpler fighter.

Kurzinfo

  • WHO: Justin Bronk, Senior Research Fellow for Airpower and Technology, RUSI; editor of RUSI Defence Systems
  • Interview: Tages-Anzeiger, Dominique Eigenmann, 12 November 2026
  • On drones: They can cause damage and wear an enemy down, but not win a war
  • On air policing: Drones cannot replace piloted fighters in peacetime missions
  • On Switzerland: The Gripen E would be a simpler and, over its life, considerably cheaper option than the F-35
  • On China: Building J-20s and J-16s in large numbers rather than mass-producing unmanned combat aircraft

“Damage, but No Victory”

Bronk’s central point is that Ukraine is a misleading model. Both sides there have strong air defences but no Western-style air forces, which is why, after four and a half years of war, Russia still has no air superiority. Drone swarms have made large ground offensives almost impossible on the Ukrainian front, he says, but only because minefields, obstacles and anti-tank weapons have already frozen the front lines. Where those conditions are missing, armoured forces still break through.

“With drones you can do damage, you can fight a war of attrition with them, but you cannot win a war.”
Justin Bronk — RUSI, to the Tages-Anzeiger, 12 November 2026 (translated)

What drones also cannot do, he argues, is the peacetime job most air forces spend most of their time on: air policing. Showing presence, escorting aircraft and watching contested borders need a human in the cockpit who understands the political context and can read another pilot’s behaviour. And as long as airliners are not flown by robots, he said, peacetime rules will not let robots shoot down other aircraft.

Bronk on the limits of drones in a longer conversation. Video: Ward Carroll.

The F-35 and Switzerland

On Switzerland’s own purchase, Bronk was blunt. The F-35 was built to attack high-value Russian or Chinese targets such as air defence sites and modern fighters, he said, and it is questionable whether that matches any real task for a neutral country surrounded by friends. For air policing and air defence, simpler options such as the Swedish Gripen E would be considerably cheaper over the aircraft’s life.

Schweizer Luftwaffe F/A-18 Hornet
A Swiss Air Force F/A-18 Hornet taking off from Payerne. The Hornets are due to retire around 2032, which is why Switzerland needs a new fighter. Photo: Peter Gronemann, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The debate is far from academic in Switzerland. Voters approved buying new fighters by just 50.1 percent in 2020, and the government picked the F-35A in June 2021 over the Rafale, Eurofighter and Super Hornet. The Gripen had already been turned down by voters in 2014. The contract for 36 jets was signed in September 2022, but after a dispute over what had been presented as a fixed price, the Federal Council decided in December 2025 and March 2026 not to fund the full 36; around 30 are now expected. In September 2026 a parliamentary oversight committee found that a lump-sum fixed price had never been contractually agreed. Swiss pilots are due to start training on the first eight jets in the United States in mid-2027, and the first jet is to arrive in Switzerland in 2028.

Why China Builds Fighters

Bronk’s strongest evidence that fighters are not obsolete comes from China. Despite having the world’s largest drone industry, he says, China runs half a dozen unmanned combat aircraft programmes but mass-produces none of them. Instead it is building around 120 J-20 stealth fighters and 100 J-16s a year, along with large numbers of air-to-air missiles, and developing two sixth-generation designs. Within five years, he predicts, China will be able to challenge US air superiority up to 2,000 kilometres off its east coast.

Chengdu J-20
A Chengdu J-20 at Airshow China. Bronk says China builds about 120 a year. Photo: Alert5, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
“Some expect a similar revolution in the air, but so far I cannot see it, however hard I try.”
Justin Bronk — to the Tages-Anzeiger, 12 November 2026 (translated)

He is also sceptical of the idea that sixth-generation fighters like the F-47, the J-36 and J-50 and GCAP will fly with swarms of loyal wingmen. To be useful, he argues, such unmanned escorts will be expensive enough that not even China or the United States can afford thousands of them. His summary: an evolution of air warfare, not a revolution.

Bronk on what European air forces need. Video: RUSI.

Sources: Tages-Anzeiger, Dominique Eigenmann, “Mit Drohnen kann man Schaden anrichten, aber keinen Krieg gewinnen” (12 November 2026); RUSI, Justin Bronk profile; Swiss Federal Council and VBS releases (30 June 2021, 12 December 2025, 6 March 2026, 14 August 2026); Swiss Parliament, GPK-N report (8 September 2026); Swissinfo; Breaking Defense (March 2026); Defense News (2020, 2022); Air Force Research Laboratory (XQ-58A test, March 2021).

Häufig gestellte Fragen

Who is Justin Bronk?
Justin Bronk is Senior Research Fellow for Airpower and Technology at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) in London and editor of RUSI Defence Systems. He is a private pilot and has flown in the back seat of fast jets with a dozen air forces.
Does Justin Bronk think drones will replace fighter jets?
No. In a November 2026 interview with the Tages-Anzeiger, Justin Bronk said drones can cause damage and sustain a war of attrition but cannot win a war, and that they cannot replace piloted fighters for air policing or for winning air superiority.
What did Justin Bronk say about Switzerland’s F-35?
Justin Bronk questioned whether the F-35, designed to attack high-value Russian or Chinese targets, matches a real task for neutral Switzerland. He said simpler options such as the Saab Gripen E would be considerably cheaper over their life for air policing and air defence.
How many F-35s is Switzerland buying?
Switzerland signed for 36 F-35As in 2022, but after a dispute over the price the Federal Council decided in 2025 and 2026 not to fund all 36. Around 30 are now expected; the first jets are due to arrive in Switzerland in 2028.
Why did Switzerland not choose the Gripen?
Swiss voters rejected the purchase of 22 Gripen fighters in a 2014 referendum. In the later Air2030 competition the government chose the F-35A in June 2021 over the Rafale, Eurofighter and Super Hornet.
How many J-20s does China build?
Justin Bronk told the Tages-Anzeiger that China builds about 120 J-20 stealth fighters and 100 J-16s a year. Open-source estimates of the total J-20 fleet vary, with several hundred in service by 2026.

Ähnliche Beiträge

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *